Pro Se Project / Immigration / How to Appeal an Immigration Judge's Decision
Immigration

How to appeal an immigration judge's decision

If you disagree with a decision made by the immigration judge handling your case, you can ask the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) to review it. This review is called an appeal. Your appeal must be received by the BIA within 30 days of the immigration judge's decision. This guide walks you through that appeal process: the forms you need, the fee required, and where to file your paperwork.

This guide is general information to help you understand the process. It is not legal advice and is not a substitute for a lawyer who knows your case.
At a glance

Three crucial details

There is a 30-day deadline

The BIA must receive your appeal within 30 calendar days of the judge's decision — weekends and holidays included. Miss it and the immigration judge's decision becomes final.

Appeals cost money

There is currently a $1,030 filing fee. This rate changes over time. If you cannot pay, a fee waiver request is available.

Keep your address updated

Appeals can take months or years. During that time it is your obligation to keep your address current with the immigration courts so they can reach you.

Deadline calculator
Your appeal must be received by
This is an estimate to help you plan. The Board must receive your appeal (not just have it postmarked) by the deadline, so always mail well in advance and confirm your exact deadline.
Step 1

Is an appeal the right step for me?

An appeal is your chance to ask a different judge — who works for the Board of Immigration Appeals ("the Board" or "BIA") — to review the immigration judge's decision because you believe the judge made a legal or factual mistake.

If, instead, you have new facts or evidence that came up after the decision, or you want the same judge to take another look because they misunderstood something already in the record, a motion to reopen or motion to reconsider filed with the immigration court may be the better tool.

This guide explains how to file an appeal, which is a separate process from a motion to reopen or reconsider.

An appeal is not the same as a motion to reopen or reconsider

Motions to reopen and reconsider have their own separate deadlines and rules. If you're unsure which fits your situation, talk to a lawyer before you file.

Step 2

How to file an appeal

Once you've decided that an appeal to the BIA is the right route, you file paperwork called a "Notice of Appeal from a Decision of an Immigration Judge" (Form EOIR-26). The most recent edition is always on the immigration court website.

The form has 12 sections across seven pages, and every question needs a response. We explain what each question is asking for below, question by question. Tap any question to see what to enter.

Question 1

List the names & A-numbers of everyone appealing

Box 1, page 1 — only the people you list here are part of the appeal.

A "respondent" is what the court calls someone who appeared in immigration court. The BIA only reviews the respondents named on the Notice of Appeal — anyone not named is assumed to accept the judge's decision. So list every respondent from your case.

Write each person's legal name in Box 1, and next to each name write that person's A-number (Alien Number) — the 9-digit number the government uses to identify each person. Find it on the judge's decision or your other court paperwork.

Question 2

Are you the Respondent/Applicant, or DHS/ICE?

Mark "Respondent/Applicant."

Either side can file this form. Because you are appealing your own case, mark the box for "Respondent/Applicant."

Question 3

Are you detained or not detained?

Mark the box that matches your situation.

If you are filing while in immigration detention, mark "detained." If you are not in detention, mark "not detained."

Question 4

Where was your last hearing?

Write the immigration court that issued your decision.

Immigration courts have names. Write the name of the court that held your last hearing, plus its city and state. For example, if your last hearing was at the Denver Immigration Court, you could write:

ExampleDenver Immigration Court,
Denver, Colorado
Question 5

What decision are you appealing?

You can appeal only one decision per form. Pick the box that fits and write its date.

Each decision needs its own appeal. The form lists four types of decisions — check the one this appeal is about and write the date the judge issued it:

Merits proceedings. The final decision in your case (for example, removal, deportation, exclusion, or asylum). If you were in deportation proceedings, lost, and the judge ordered you removed, this is the box — then write the date of that decision.

Bond proceedings. You asked to be released from detention at a bond hearing, and the judge decided you did not qualify for bond or set a bond amount far too high. Check this and write the date of the bond decision.

Denial of a motion to reopen or reconsider. Your case was previously denied, you filed a motion to reopen or reconsider instead of appealing, and the judge denied that motion. Important: this appeal is limited to the denial of that motion — it is not an appeal of the substance of your case.

Interlocutory appeal. Challenges an issue that comes up while the case is still going. For example, if you filed a Motion to Change Venue to move your court and the judge denied it, you can appeal that decision.

Question 6

State in detail the reasons for this appeal

The most important box. A vague answer can get your appeal dismissed.

This is the heart of your appeal, and it deserves its own section. Below we explain exactly how to answer Question 6, with seven common, specific reasons you can adapt to your case.

Question 7

Do you want oral argument before the BIA?

Your choice — but you must mark Yes or No.

Oral arguments before the BIA are rare, and they're situations where it's best to have a qualified immigration attorney present. Marking "No" will not hurt your case. It is your decision to mark Yes or No, but you must mark one of them.

Question 8

Will you file a separate written brief?

Tells the BIA whether a fuller legal argument is coming.

This asks whether you will file a full written legal argument for the BIA to consider, or rely only on what you wrote in Question 6. If you mark "Yes," the BIA will notify you in writing when your brief is due. If you mark "No," the BIA will review only the judge's decision and what you wrote on this form as the full record.

Question 9

Signature of the person appealing

The lead respondent prints their name, signs, and dates.

The lead respondent — the person whose case was most central to the judge's decision — prints their name in the top box, signs the middle box, and writes the date in the bottom box.

Question 10

Mailing address of respondents/applicants

Where the BIA sends everything — make it reliable.

The lead respondent who signed should write their name, address, and telephone number here. This is where the BIA sends all mail about your appeal, so it must be an address where mail arrives reliably and promptly.

Question 11

Mailing address of attorney or representative

Write "N/A" — you're filing on your own.

If you're using this guide, we assume you don't have an attorney. Simply write "N/A" in the name box and move on. If an attorney joins your case later, they'll file a separate paper asking the BIA to add them.

Question 12

Proof of Service

Show that you mailed a copy to the ICE government attorney.

It's not enough to send your paperwork to the BIA — in immigration court you must also notify the government attorneys at Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). This section has six boxes:

  1. The name of the person mailing the copy to ICE.
  2. The date you actually mail the copy to ICE.
  3. Write: "Assistant Chief Counsel of DHS — ICE."
  4. The address of the ICE office for your court (use the finder in Step 5).
  5. Leave the box unchecked — you're mailing your copy, not submitting it online.
  6. The signature of the person mailing the copy.
ExampleI, Maria Garcia, mailed or delivered a copy of this Notice of Appeal on August 28, 2026 to Assistant Chief Counsel of DHS — ICE at 12445 E Caley Avenue, Centennial, Colorado 80111.  [Signature]
Step 3

Pay for your appeal — or request a waiver

Before you mail your appeal, you must pay the fee and print your receipt to attach to your packet. The current cost is $1,030, but this changes.

Go to the EOIR payment portal. In the dropdown, select "BIA – Appeal (new filing of a Form EOIR-26)." It will show the price and take you to a payment screen. Print your receipt and keep a copy for your records.

Requesting a fee waiver

If you cannot afford this fee, complete the Fee Waiver Request (Form EOIR-26A) instead. Describe your income, assets, and monthly expenses in detail and sign under penalty of perjury that you cannot pay. Attach whatever proof you have — recent pay stubs (or a statement that you have no income), proof of any public benefits, or documentation of your detention status. The clearer and more complete the picture of your finances, the more likely the Board is to approve it.

If you request a waiver and the Board denies it, you'll need to pay the $1,030 fee for your appeal to move forward — so file your waiver as early as you can.

Step 4

Compile your packet for mailing

Before you mail, make sure your packet has
Run through this list before you send anything:
  • A completed Form EOIR-26, filled out in English and signed.
  • A copy of the immigration judge's decision (or the order you are appealing).
  • A copy of your payment receipt, or a completed Fee Waiver Request (Form EOIR-26A).
  • A certified English translation for any attachment that is not in English.
Step 5

Mailing your appeal

You will need three copies of your packet: one to mail to the BIA, one to mail to ICE, and one to keep for yourself.

Mail the BIA packet to:

Board of Immigration AppealsClerk's Office
5107 Leesburg Pike, Suite 2000
Falls Church, VA 22041
Find the ICE office to serve
Mail a copy of your appeal to
Addresses can change. Confirm the current office at ice.gov/contact/field-offices. Remember: the original appeal still goes to the Board of Immigration Appeals in Falls Church, VA, and if you are detained you should also give a copy to your deportation officer.
The key box

How to write a detailed answer to Question 6

Question 6 on Form EOIR-26 says, "State in detail the reasons for this appeal." Below the box is a warning:

The form's warning"You must clearly explain the specific facts and law on which you base your appeal of the Immigration Judge's decision. The Board may summarily dismiss your appeal if it cannot tell from this Notice of Appeal, or any statements attached to this Notice of Appeal, why you are appealing."

So your answer to Question 6 must be detailed, organized, and thorough. It is not enough to say, "I believe I should win my case and I disagree with the Immigration Judge." That will not work. You need to point to specific ways the immigration judge made a mistake in your case.

Below are seven of the most common reasons someone may need to appeal — use whichever fit, and fill in the specifics of your own case:

The immigration court proceeding I attended was defective because I could not understand the interpreter.
I attended my immigration court proceedings without a lawyer, and the immigration judge did not do his/her job to develop the full record of my case.
The judge denied my asylum case because he/she thought I did not suffer past persecution. He/she is wrong because …
The judge denied my asylum case because he/she thought I had not proven that the government in my home country was unable or unwilling to protect me. He/she is wrong because …
The judge denied my case for cancellation of removal because he/she said my qualifying relatives would not suffer the required hardship. This is wrong because …
The judge denied my asylum case through pretermission because he/she said I had not demonstrated my eligibility for asylum. This is wrong because …
The judge denied my asylum case because he/she said I did not apply within one year. This is wrong because I qualify for an exception to the one-year filing rule because …

Your answer can use just one of these or several at once. What matters is that you are specific about why the immigration judge was wrong in your case, and that you back up your arguments with the law or facts that support your side.

Questions

Frequently asked

No. While your appeal is pending before the Board, the government cannot remove you or place you in expedited removal. It is not legally possible to have an appeal pending with the Board and be in expedited removal at the same time. If you are detained and ICE tries to move forward, tell your deportation officer that your appeal must be decided first.
File a Fee Waiver Request (Form EOIR-26A) with your appeal. You'll describe your income, assets, and expenses, attach any proof you have (recent pay stubs or a statement that you have no income, proof of public benefits, or your detention status), and sign under penalty of perjury that you cannot pay. If you're detained with no income, say so in the explanation section. You must include either payment or a completed fee waiver, or the appeal will be rejected. If the Board denies your fee waiver, you'll need to pay the fee for the appeal to continue.
The Board mails you a filing receipt. If you don't get one within about two weeks, check your status at acis.eoir.justice.gov using your A-number, or call 1-800-898-7180. The Board then sends the hearing transcript, the judge's decision, and a deadline for your written brief. When it decides, the Board can agree with the immigration judge, rule in your favor, or send your case back to the judge for further proceedings — and it will mail you its written decision.
Tell the Board right away. You must report any change of address or phone number within five business days, using Form EOIR-33/BIA. This matters: the Board mails your briefing schedule and its final decision to the address on file, so if it is out of date you can miss your brief deadline and lose the appeal.
No. On the Notice of Appeal, explain the specific reasons you're appealing, but you can note that you reserve the right to raise more arguments after you receive the record and find a lawyer. Your detailed legal argument goes in the brief you file later, once the Board sends the briefing schedule. Be aware the Board can dismiss an appeal if it truly can't tell why you're appealing, so give real detail.
Search the nonprofit legal directory at immigrationadvocates.org/nonprofit/legaldirectory. Your attorney can be located anywhere in the U.S. as long as they're authorized to practice before the Department of Justice. Only a licensed attorney or an authorized representative from a recognized organization can represent you — beware of "notarios," who are not authorized to give legal advice in the United States.
If the Board does not receive your appeal within 30 days of the judge's decision, it will not consider the appeal and the judge's decision becomes final. Because the Board must physically receive it in time, mail well before the deadline and keep proof of mailing. If you have already missed the 30-day deadline, your removal order from the immigration judge will become final — speak to an immigration attorney immediately about your remaining options.

Facing an appeal deadline?

The 30-day window is short and the rules are strict. If you're not sure what to do, call us — a consultation is just a phone call away.

Denver, CO
(303) 335-0250
Seattle Area — Kent
(206) 212-0260
Walla Walla, WA
(888) 746-5245
Or email us anytime — ucan@novo-legal.com